Oliver, an eleventh-grade Beta with poor grades, is forced to retake algebra, where he meets Ethan, a brilliant but arrogant student who reminds him of his childhood friend Alan.
Unknown to Oliver, both boys have feelings for him. When Alan discovers Ethan’s secret love letter, jealousy sparks a rivalry. Ethan begins tutoring Oliver, while Alan finally admits his own feelings. The two agree to compete for Oliver’s heart once he enters university.
But at graduation, Oliver unexpectedly undergoes a second differentiation and desperately needs an Alpha by his side. With Ethan and Alan both determined to claim his heart, Oliver must face a choice that could change their lives.