🔎 Welcome to Evidence Bag Stories — where every clue has a story.
Stephen McCullagh appeared to have the perfect alibi.
On the night Natalie McNally was killed, he seemed to be live on YouTube for hours, gaming from home.
But investigators discovered something that changed the entire case: the six-hour “livestream” had actually been recorded four days earlier and broadcast as if it were live. CCTV, travel records and digital evidence then began to tell a very different story. McCullagh was ultimately convicted of Natalie’s murder and sentenced to life with a minimum term of 31 years.
In this episode of Evidence Bag Stories, we follow the fake alibi, the CCTV trail and the digital evidence that exposed one of the most unusual murder cover-ups in recent years.
How long could the livestream have fooled investigators if they hadn’t looked closer?